NYC Ballet's (Mis)Adventures with Bournonville: Part Four, 5/24 Performance of 'La Sylphide'

Before we saw the all-Bournonville program at NYC Ballet on Sunday, May 24th, I had attended a dress rehearsal of 'La Sylphide' on May 5th and together we went to the NYCB Seminar on " Peter Martins' 'La Sylphide' and the Bournonville Style" on May 18th.  This is the fourth of four posts about these events.


La Sylphide:
SUNDAY MATINEE, MAY 24, 3:00 PM [Conductor: Capps]
LA SYLPHIDE: Lovette, Huxley, King, Schumacher, Smith, Muller

During the Spring season the Company programmed eight performances of Bournonville's 'La Sylphide' with four different principal casts.  After seeing the opening night cast at the May 5th dress rehearsal, I was pleased to see another excellent cast on May 24th.  At this performance I was less distracted by the sets and able to concentrate more on the dancing and mime.

Lauren Lovette as the Sylph and Anthony Huxley as James in Act II of Bournonville's 'La Sylphide'.
Photo by Paul Kolnik for NYC Ballet

Lauren Lovette made a lovely, airborne Sylph filled with mischievous joy.  She has a very expressive face with large sparkling eyes which she uses to captivate the audience as well as James.  Her dancing was both fleet and secure.  

Anthony Huxley as James executed the beats and spacious jumps of the role with elan and his mime scenes were delivered with clarity and force.  For such a reserved dancer, this was an impressive breakthrough into a more expansive, confident performing style.

Lauren King was lovely as the baffled Effie and Troy Schumacher's Gurn was an earthy, grounded rival of the daydreaming James for Effie's hand in marriage.  Gretchen Smith's old crone, Madge, lacked the overwhelming sense of aggrievement that should provide the basis for her actions.  Gwyneth Muller looks like James' older sister rather than his mother.

The Royal Danish Ballet has a different life cycle for dancers than NYC Ballet.  RBD can move dancers on from dance roles to character roles as they mature.  It's in keeping with the Danish welfare state to provide dancers with meaningful work as they mature while giving the RBD a ready supply of character dancers for roles like Madge and James' mother.  NYC Ballet lacks the resources or infrastructure to support such a system -- although Darci Kistler, Jock Soto and Albert Evans did take on character parts in Peter Martins' 'Romeo+Juliet'.  This puts a burden on young dancers in mime-heavy ballets like 'La Sylphide'.  Not only do they have to learn the mime gestures, but they must also do it as characters who are two or three times as old as they are. 

Act II of Peter Martins' staging of Bournonville's 'La Sylphide' for New York City Ballet.
Photo by Paul Kolnik for NYC Ballet

The corps of sylphs in Act II danced as if they had been dancing in the Bournonville style their entire lives.  While there is some lovely dancing in Act II, as a whole 'La Sylphide' is about half mime and lacks the urgency and excitement that is at the heart of the Company's dance profile.  

As an exercise in expanding and improving the Company's dance technique, the restaging of 'Bournonville Divertissements' and the introduction of 'La Sylphide' was entirely successful.  However, I don't think that New York City Ballet's audience is ready for an entire evening (or afternoon) of Bournonville.  In fact, it quickly becomes boring and repetitious.

NYC Ballet's (Mis)Adventures with Bournonville: Part Three, Dress Rehearsal of 'La Sylphide'

Before we saw the all-Bournonville program at NYC Ballet on Sunday, May 24th, I had attended a dress rehearsal of 'La Sylphide' on May 5th and together we went to the NYCB Seminar on " Peter Martins' 'La Sylphide' and the Bournonville Style" on May 18th.  This is the third of four posts about these events.

May 5th Dress Rehearsal for 'La Sylphide':
I attended the piano dress rehearsal for 'La Sylphide' on Tuesday, May 5th, which was lead by Peter Martins and  Petrusjka Broholm with the opening night (May 7th) cast including:  Sterling Hyltin (Sylph), Joaquin De Luz (James), Daniel Ulbricht (Gurn) and Georgina Pazcoguin (Madge).

I was struck by Peter Martins' detailed coaching of the mime passages which are important in conveying the plot.  He spent quite a bit of time working with Joaquin De Luz and Georgina Pazcoguin on the mime passage where Madge reluctantly gives James the poisoned scarf.

I found Susan Tammany's sets for both acts very distracting, making it hard to concentrate on the dancers and the dancing.  In the Act I Manor-House set, the fireplace and beams created too many strong diagonals.  In the Act II Forest set, the complicated backdrop of trees and clouds and moon which I had loved in the promotional materials seemed to distract from the sylphs dancing in their natural environment.

Sterling Hyltin and Joaquin De Luz in the opening scene of 'La Sylphide'.  Photo by Paul Kolnik for NYC Ballet

Ms. Hyltin and Mr. De Luz, although mismatched in height, danced brilliantly.  His precise beats and wonderful elevation make him ideal for the Bournonville choreography.  Ms. Hyltin danced with both airiness and new found technical strength and looked like a 19th century lithograph come to life.  Mr. Ulbricht seemed wasted on the small part of Gurn.  Ms. Pazcoguin, the Company's finest mime artist, played Madge with wonderful expressiveness and clarity.  

Here's a link to a video of Ms. Hyltin and Mr. De Luz dancing in Act II:
  
https://www.facebook.com/nycballet/videos/vb.112319735528/10155556052500529/?type=2&theater

And here's a link to Sterling and Joaquin dancing with the corps of sylphs:

https://www.facebook.com/nycballet/videos/10155576659685529/

Note that the single partnered moment in this ballet is the one at the end of this second clip.

NYC Ballet's (Mis)Adventures with Bournonville: Part Two, The Seminar

Before we saw the all-Bournonville program at NYC Ballet on Sunday, May 24th, I had attended a dress rehearsal of 'La Sylphide' on May 5th and together we went to the NYC Ballet Seminar: 'La Sylphide' and the Bournonville Style on May 18th.  This is the second of four posts about these events.

May 18th Seminar: "Peter Martins' 'La Sylphide' & the Bournonville Style":
On May 18th we attended the NYC Ballet seminar about 'La Sylphide' and Bournonville style.  It was moderated by Faye Arthurs -- a long-time member of the company.  In addition to Peter Martins, the panelists included the lead dancers from the first cast of 'La Sylphide' -- Sterling Hyltin, Joaquin De Luz and Georgina Pazcoguin; the stager, Petrusjka Broholm; the stage manager, Marquerite Mehler; and the set and costume designer, Susan Tammany.

Ms. Arthurs first presented a brief history of 'La Sylphide' which originated at the Paris Opera Ballet in 1832 in a production made by Filippo Taglioni as a vehicle for his daughter, Marie Taglioni.  The score was by Jean-Madeleine Schneitzhoeffer.  It was the first ballet that integrated dancing en pointe into the plot.  Taglioni had her skirts shortened -- which was considered scandalous -- to show off her excellent pointe work.

Marie Taglinoni dancing 'La Sylphide' in Filippo Taglinoni's Paris Opera production of 1832.

Bournonville saw 'La Sylphide' in Paris and began to prepare a production for Copenhagen.  Stymied by the high price demanded by the Paris Opera for Schneitzhoeffer's score, he commissioned a new score from the Danish composer Herman Severin Lovenskjold.  The Sylph was danced by Lucile Grahn and Bournonville himself danced James.  The Danish version premiered in 1836 and has remained in the Royal Danish Ballet's active repertory ever since.

It is this version that Peter Martins danced in as a child and later in the mid-1960's he danced the role of James with the Royal Danish Ballet.  He staged this version in 1985 for the Pennsylvania Ballet with decor by the artist Susan Tammany.  
In discussing Ms. Tammany's sets, Ms. Arthurs showed a slide of  'Mountains at Collioure' painted in 1905 by the Fauvist, Andre Derain.  With the Act II 'La Sylphide' set behind and the Derain painting on a large screen in the center it is certainly plausible to see the connection between Ms. Tammany's set design:

Backdrop by Susan Tammany for Act II of Peter Martins' staging of 'La Sylphide'.

and Derain's painting:

'Mountains at Collioure' by Andre Derain, oil on canvas, 1905.

In discussing the costume designs, Ms. Tammany noted that the colors for the tartans of the three main human characters were chosen to reflect aspects of their characters -- blues and purples for James, the dreamer; browns and rusts for Gurn, the practical farmer, and blues and greens for Effie, the optimist. 

Skirts in tartans for (left to right) Effie's clan, James' clan, and Gurn's clan in NYC Ballet's Costume Shop.
Photo from NYC Ballet website.

Petrusjka Broholm, the stager, worked with the company for eight months teaching and perfecting its Bournonville dancing in order to mount 'La Sylphide' in the Danish style.  All of the dancers on the panel -- Ms. Hiltyn, Mr. De Luz, Ms. Pazcoguin, and Ms. Arthurs -- agreed that Ms. Broholm's Bournonville classes had improved and strengthened their overall technique.

Peter Martins spoke briefly about the importance of effective mime passages for the audience's understanding and appreciation of 'La Sylphide' and of the need to train NYC Ballet dancers in the Danish style of mime.  All of the dancers expressed the view that Peter really wanted to play the mime role of Madge, the old fortune teller and witch, but Peter denied it.

Peter Martins working on a mime passage with Georgina Pazgoquin (Madge) and Joaquin de Luz (James).

This was an impressive debut for Faye Arthurs as a seminar moderator.  She had clearly prepared for the program with extensive research and had a definite agenda that she followed, but with enough flexibility to allow the panelists to expand on their responses to her questions and make additional comments where appropriate.  It was also to her credit that there was enough information presented that there were only two questions/comments from the audience. (The questions and comments from the audience are usually the low point of the NYC Ballet seminars, since they are often silly or self-serving.  So the less, the better in our view.)
  
The seminar handout points out that Ms. Arthurs was the valedictorian when she graduated from Fordham University and from her performance here we know why.  You can read Faye's blog, 'Thoughts from the Paint' here:

http://www.thoughtsfromthepaint.com/

It's interesting to read about NYC Ballet from the viewpoint of an intelligent, articulate dancer immersed in the company's activities.